Some marketing campaigns spread organically because they are unique, solve a problem for lots of people, or are so insanely out of touch that people can’t help but share them. Others succeed because some brilliant marketers understand how to make campaigns look organic when they are really guerilla marketing with lots of costs associated with spreading them.
We’ll discuss the reasons that some marketing campaigns succeed and others fail by discussing aspects of great marketing campaigns, aspects of poor performing campaigns, and why sometimes it’s just marketers using techniques that you aren’t aware exist.
Click on any of the links below to jump ahead.
What Do Successful Viral Marketing Campaigns Have In Common?
There are a number of reasons why some marketing campaigns succeed while others fail. Viral organic marketing campaigns normally have the following characteristics.
Validate The Idea Early
Liquid Death created a commercial before ever manufacturing their cans of water. The response to the campaign defended the hypothesis and justified sending the product into production.
Get Attention Fast
You have less than 2 seconds to get someone’s attention. That’s why YouTube thumbnails and the first sentence in a real are so important.
Appeal To A Person’s Desire To Feel Special.
Everyone wants to create an image where people perceive them the way they are or want to be. Companies and marketers use this through luxury brand pricing, limited time offers, or gamified offers.
Incorporate Triggers To Keep People Coming Back
Triggers are environmental cues that remind people of your product. If something is top-of-mind, it is tip-of-tongue. For example, Rebecca Black’s song “Friday” went viral largely because every Friday, people had an automatic trigger to think about it and search for it.
Provide High Levels Of Positive Emotions
People share more when a campaign is exciting, amusing, or creates justful indignation. We like our marketing campaigns to trigger our dopamine responses.
Offer Physical Products That Stand Out
When people can see your products it’s much easier to picture owning them. Home service businesses use this all the time with before and after pictures.
Are you providing branded products too? You might be missing a great opportunity to keep your brand in people’s minds. An HVAC company could provide a year’s worth of branded filters with every new AC purchase or a cleaning company could provide every customer with a branded toilet bowl cleaner.
Provide Real Value
People love to help others by sharing content that saves people time, money, or improves their life.That’s why every major content creator provides “life hacks,” tutorials, and listicles in the hopes that they go viral. These can drive traffic for years. For instance, seven of the UpFlip blogs talking about best businesses still show up in AI overviews nearly two years later.
Wrap The Information In A Story
It should be no surprise that marketing campaigns that tell a story tend to do better than those just selling a product or service. People like telling and listening to stories and most don’t love memorizing information in school.
You’ll probably never forget this video after seeing it.
Use The Right Type Of Hook
Organic and ad campaigns can’t use the same types of hooks. Organic campaigns want to bring as many people in as possible while ad campaigns want to disqualify as many non-buyers as quickly as possible.
| Type Of Hook | Goal | How It Works | When To Use It |
|---|---|---|---|
| Broad Relatable Hook | Maximize unpaid viral reach across generalized platform feeds. | Leverages universal human experiences or broad industry pain points to achieve maximum 3-second thumb stops. | Organic feeds (TikTok, Instagram Reels, YouTube Shorts). |
| Big Promise Hook | State commercial outcome directly to capture high-intent prospects. | Eliminates context and warmup; states immediate financial or functional value proposition directly. | Direct Response Paid Ads. |
| Client Callout Hook | Explicitly select narrow ideal customer profiles. | Identifies job title, revenue tier, or specific operational parameters directly in the opening line. | B2B Paid Media, Mid-Funnel Retargeting. |
| Disqualifier Hook | Filter out non-converting traffic before paying for ad impressions. | Actively tells unqualified audiences to skip (e.g., “Do not watch if doing under $30k/month”). | High-Ticket B2B & DTC Paid Campaigns. |
| Problem Reenactment | Establish instant situational identification without dialogue. | Visually demonstrates a painful operational scenario within 2 seconds. | Paid Acquisition Creative. |
Why Do Seemingly Good Marketing Campaigns Fail?
Failure To Understand The Target Market
When you don’t truly understand the market, you may make decisions that look good on paper, but may not work well practically.
For instance, people tend to judge products and services based on either price or value. People who judge them based on price are not the ideal customers for most businesses because they will create more callbacks and not fix the actual problem, then you have to give them a refund or fix the problem at a loss.
Meanwhile, a person that cares about value is unlikely to consider companies at the bottom half of the costs because they likely cut corners to save on costs.
Bad Execution Can Kill A Marketing Campaign
When trying to create organic demand, bad execution can prevent people from sharing it organically. For instance, Quibi attempted to create a cross between TikTok and Netflix, but made a technical decision to block screenshots and recording, which are crucial for creating viral content like memes.
Bad Timing Makes Good Ideas Fail
In addition to the lack of screenshots, Quibi failed because providing short-form (under 10 minutes) videos for a subscription fee during the pandemic made no sense because commuting was limited during the time.
Sometimes The Marketing Just Doesn’t Work
We’ve all seen marketing fails that were unintentionally racist, homophobic, or containing questionable songs. Check out these marketing fails. If you need a degenerate to check your marketing before you release it, reach out, and I’ll be happy to check it.
Sometimes Marketing Isn’t As Organic As It Looks
Today, technology allows people to use AI and APIs to create the appearance of activity when there is much less than appears. Here’s what you need to know:
- According to an Imperva study, 53% of internet traffic is bots.
- University of Cambridge found that it costs less than $.20 to create fake accounts.
- It costs less than $20 to make content appear to go viral, according to this study.
All of this is highly unethical, and I would never suggest doing it, but there are more ethical ways to get similar benefits.
For instance, you could provide a system for your employees to like, comment on, and share your posts. They are real people and want the company to succeed, but are probably too busy to find, like, comment, and share each one manually.
I’m working on figuring out the best way to help businesses automate viral marketing strategies, but social media channels have lots of rules in place that prevent bots, so it may not be possible to be fully automated.
Conclusion
Marketing campaigns require a combination of skills, timing, and checking to make sure you didn’t make a dumb mistake. Even if you do everything right they might fail. Avoid using dirty tricks to advance your marketing because they can hurt you in the long run. This post is based on a the AI generated report Organic Campaign Success Dynamics.
Leave a Reply